Food Lifestyle

How to Make Nut & Seed Butters

10 min read

Nuts and seeds, consumed in moderation, can be among the healthiest foods around. And one of the ways we love our nuts and seeds is in the form of spreads and butters. But store-bought versions can be costly, and sometimes come with not-so-great ingredients. So how hard is it to make our own healthy nut and seed butters at home?

You’re probably not thinking, “Well, if Elvis Presley loved eating it, it must be good for me.”

Elvis sure could sing, but he was not what most people would consider a connoisseur of wholesome food. According to biographers, he was extremely fond of a sandwich consisting of two large slices of bread, sliced banana, peanut butter, and bacon, all fried in bacon grease — an oversized sandwich that comes in at around 8,000 calories. This is not, needless to say, a recipe that you would ever find on the Food Revolution Network website.

But that doesn’t mean we need to throw out the whole idea of nut and seed butters. Done right, they can be a delicious and versatile part of a healthy diet. After all, nuts and seeds provide myriad health benefits, as we’ll see below. And for many people, the main way to enjoy these benefits is through nut butters or seed butters. The spreadable pastes are used as sandwich fillings, sauce thickeners, baking ingredients, and in countless other ways.

While peanut butter has been touted as an inexpensive protein source the world over, some nut butters can be quite expensive. And some commercial varieties contain additional ingredients that, like Elvis’s bacon, may be questionable for your health.

Another strike against commercial nut and seed butters is that once they are ground, the fats begin to degrade and can go rancid. Fresh is best, but with store-bought butters, that may not be an option.

If you want fresh, delicious, affordable, and clean nut and seed butters, your best bet is probably to make your own. In this article, you’ll discover exactly how — and get some amazing recipes for homemade butters that can add health to your life and deliciousity (yes, spellcheck, that really is a word!) to your kitchen.

Types of Nut and Seeds

You can make nut butter or seed butter out of pretty much any food that’s eaten like a nut or seed. The most common, of course, is peanut butter, which isn’t a nut at all, but a legume.

I’ve known this for years, but only in writing this article did I realize that I wasn’t actually sure about the difference. It turns out that a nut is a fruit with a single seed, while legumes are fruits with multiple seeds. So almonds, walnuts, and hazelnuts are all single inside their hulls, while peanuts typically occur in pairs or even trios inside their shells, more like their legume siblings peas, beans, and lentils.


Now you know why peanuts aren’t botanically considered to be nuts. But along with peanuts, almost any nut can be turned into a nut butter, including almonds, cashews, pecans, hazelnuts, pistachios, Brazil nuts, walnuts, and macadamia nuts. 


What about seeds? Nuts have seeds, but aren’t seeds? Oh dear, more taxonomic confusion. While not getting deep into the biology of plant reproduction (this is a family-friendly website, after all), we can keep it simple by saying that nuts have hard shells (called pericarps) that we have to work to crack open, while seeds are encased in seed coats that are relatively easy to remove. Sunflowers blur the line, but in many cultures, (including American baseball) popping handfuls of sunflower seeds in the mouth and expertly spitting out the shells is a fine art. No nutcracker required.

There are a bunch of seeds that are commonly made into seed butters, like sunflower, pumpkin, sesame (it even has its own special name: tahini), poppy, watermelon, hemp, and flax. One seed hasn’t yet made the cut, but is often included whole in seed butter mixtures: chia.

Seed butters tend to have stronger flavors than nut butters and often benefit from being blended with other seeds or nuts, rather than remaining as a single seed variety. And seed-only butters are often popular alternatives for people with nut allergies.

Nut & Seed Butter Nutrition

Perhaps unsurprisingly, nut and seed butters have a similar nutritional profile to their whole food forms. Nuts and seeds are good sources of plant-based protein, which is one reason that Dr. John Harvey Kellogg, 19th-century health food proponent and plant-based advocate, pushed for the commercial processing of peanuts into peanut butter to replace cow butter in the American diet.

Nuts and seeds are also high in fat, which from their perspective provides food for the growing plant embryo, and from our perspective, makes them creamy and delicious. The majority of the fats are what are commonly considered the “good kinds,” poly- and monounsaturated — although some do contain small amounts of problematic saturated fats. A few kinds of seeds, such as chia and flax, are also rich sources of omega-3 fatty acids.

Nuts and seeds, like many whole plant foods, are high in fiber and rich in minerals like magnesium and manganese. They’re also phytonutrient powerhouses, containing tocopherols, phytosterols, vitamin E, vitamin B6, folate, and phenolic compounds. And Brazil nuts are fantastically high in selenium.

Some nuts are more nutritionally dense than others, as you can see in this nutritional comparison table of some of the most popular nut and seed butters. All nuts (other than chestnuts) are high in fat and calories. On the upside, their high fat and calorie content makes them a good substitute for dairy in some recipes. And they can be a replacement for butter, or used in place of bottled oils, for baked goods. On the upside of that upside, most nuts and seed butters are much lower in saturated fat than dairy. For example, an ounce of peanut butter contains 2.9 grams of saturated fat, which is less than half the amount in an ounce of cheddar cheese.

The downside of all that fat is, that’s a lot of fat. And since fats are more than twice the caloric density of carbohydrates and proteins, that translates into a high-calorie content. If you’re trying to keep off excess weight, or wanting to follow a low-fat diet, you may want to watch the serving sizes of your nuts, seeds, and seed and nut butters.

Why Make Your Own Nut or Seed Butter

With all those convenient commercial jars of seed or nut butters available in stores, why bother making your own?

 1. Control the ingredients

One big reason is to keep out ingredients that can harm your health and the environment. The mainstream brands of peanut butter, like Skippy and Jif, for example, contain added sugar and salt, as well as GMO oils.

The most popular added oil, palm oil, keeps the natural peanut oil from separating, so you don’t have to stir the jar’s contents before spreading. That’s a nice feature, but the palm oil industry is responsible for some of the world’s worst environmental damage, as well as racial and economic injustices, since it developed into an international power in the late 19th century. (If you want motivation to stop eating foods containing palm oil, check out the book Planet Palm: How Palm Oil Ended Up in Everything — and Endangered the World, by Jocelyn Zuckerman.)

2. Cut down on plastic

Another reason to make your own is that many commercial nut butters are sold in plastic jars. There is concern that the plasticizers and chemicals like BPA (in the plastic jars and lids) could leach into the food.

3. Save money

Another consideration is price. With the exception of peanut butter, most other commercial nut and seed butters can get expensive. Peanuts are the cheapest option because they require less water and are less expensive to grow than tree nuts. According to the National Peanut Board, admittedly not the most neutral source, growing an ounce of peanuts requires 4.7 gallons of water, compared to 80.4 and 73.5 gallons for shelled almonds and walnuts, respectively. Being legumes, peanuts also replenish soil nitrogen, thus restoring fertility without the need for large quantities of fertilizer. So farmers can pass along all these savings to you.

Whatever the nuts or seeds cost, commercial butters add manufacturing and marketing costs (not to mention profit) on top. So no matter what nut or seed (or legume) you use, making your own butter will probably end up being cheaper than buying it.

One blogger calculated the savings of homemade vs. commercial almond butter over the course of a year, and found that a family consuming three pounds of almond butter a week (which is an awful lot of almond butter, unless you’re the Duggars) could save precisely $954.72 by grinding their own.

4. Get creative

Another reason to go the homemade route is to indulge your inner chef. You can get creative with taste and texture and produce the seed butter or nut butter mix that you and yours prefer. Of course, your own nut and seed butter ingredient lists will be simpler and healthier than store-bought (unless you add things like rapeseed oil or mono and diglycerides, which, to be fair, you’ll be hard-pressed to find at your local natural foods store). But that leaves room for some cool added flavors. Here’s a shortlist to get you inspired:

  • Cocoa powder
  • Natural sweeteners like stevia, monk fruit, and date sugar
  • Spices like chile powder, cinnamon, and cardamom
  • Vanilla extract
  • Lemon zest
  • Additional nuts or seeds to boost nutrition or add a different flavor

And since your hand is on the food processor or blender button, you get to determine exactly how smooth or crunchy the texture will be.

How to Make Nut or Seed Butter James

Your first decision is whether to roast your nuts and seeds, or go the raw route. If raw, will you grind the nuts and seeds as they are, or soak or sprout them first? Soaking them in water for a few hours, or overnight, will help you remove any paper skins, like those on peanuts and almonds, and give your finished butter a creamier texture. And sprouting nuts and seeds provides added nutritional benefits.

On the other hand, even lightly roasting helps to release the natural oils in nuts and seeds, which makes them easier to blend — and can bring out their natural flavor. It also makes your home smell like a made-for-television Thanksgiving movie, especially the ones where a jaded, burned-out ad agency executive moves to New Hampshire to take care of her convalescing mother and discovers the joys of family, romance, and wood-burning stoves.

Then comes the easy part: toss the nuts or seeds into a food processor or blender (it’s a bit like the scenic route versus the autobahn, but both will get you there) along with any additional ingredients (salt is always optional).

Blend until the mixture reaches your desired consistency, and then store your butter in an airtight container in the refrigerator. You can use a mason jar, or any other glass container. Avoid plastic, especially if the friction from blending or processing has heated up the butter. Refrigerated, the natural nut and seed butter can stay fresh for three to four weeks.

How to Use Nut and Seed Butters

Once you’ve got your jar of seed butter or nut butter lounging comfortably in the fridge, what then? I’d recommend that, most of the time, you avoid the strategy of eating all of it directly from the jar with a spoon (or worse, your fingers). That leaves several perfectly good options for how to use your seed and nut butters:

  • Spread it on whole-grain or sprouted toast — and even crudités like carrots and celery.
  • Follow the hallowed PB&J template by spreading it on your favorite bread along with natural fruit preserves or fresh fruit. Elvis may not have known when to stop, but his use of sliced bananas was truly inspired.
  • Add oomph to smoothie bowls, açaí bowls, and oatmeal by drizzling your nut butter on top.
  • Mix it into smoothies for more creaminess and flavor.
  • Drizzle some sweet nut or seed butter over Apple Nachos Supreme, or use it as a dip for other fresh fruit.
  • Use it in homemade baked goods.
  • Make an Asian stir-fry or plant-based pasta sauce (cashew butter, in particular, makes a good base for a cream sauce).

5 Nut and Seed Butter Recipes

You’ll find a variety of nut and seed butter blends below, starting with the basics like Creamy Almond Butter and Naturally Sweet Sunflower Butter. Then moving on to fancier, yet still easy-to-make, Chocolate Hazelnut Spread and Omega-3 Seedy Nut Butter. And, if you’re looking for an essential mineral boost (hello, selenium, magnesium, and zinc!) delivered in a spoonful of creamy deliciousness, then jump straight to the Brazil Cashew Nut Butter blend. Or, create your own blends using some of the recipe guidance below. The only thing we ask is that you consider sharing your nut butter blending experience with us!

1. Creamy Almond Butter

Almonds deliver an impressive amount of nutrition, including calcium, magnesium, vitamin E, and heart-healthy fats. Making your own almond butter is cost-effective and simple. It just requires a little bit of patience to get those almonds to the creamy consistency you know and love. But, trust us, it’s worth it in the end!

2. Naturally Sweet Sunflower Butter

Seeds can create the same heavenly creamy butter as nuts, thanks to their high-fat content. Seed butters are a great option if you’re allergic to nuts or simply want to add a little variety to your diet. You can make sunflower seed butter with raw sunflower seeds, but we decided to roast them. This allows their natural oils to release, which contributes to the creamy texture.

3. Chocolate Hazelnut Spread

Get ready for a delightfully sweet and nutty aroma that will permeate your home as you roast the hazelnuts for this blend. It might bring the store-bought version — full of processed sugar, palm oil, and milk powder — to mind, but this spread won’t harm your health or the environment. Wholesome ingredients like hazelnuts, date paste, and organic cacao powder create a delicious treat that’s kind to your body and the planet.

4. Omega-3 Seedy Nut Butter

This omega-powered creamy treat contains walnuts, hemp seeds, chia seeds, and flax seeds — four plant-based ingredients that provide plenty of omega-3 fatty acids as well as phytonutrients, fiber, calcium, iron, and protein. Enjoy it as a dip with your favorite fruit or veggies — apples and carrots would both make tasty, crisp companions.

5. Brazil Cashew Nut Butter

The mild, buttery flavor of Brazil nuts makes them an excellent choice for delicious nut butter. And since they’re exceptionally high in selenium (more than any other nut), a little bit goes a long way in terms of nutrition. We’ve blended in some creamy cashew butter to help balance it out with other essential nutrients like magnesium and zinc.

Get Spreading!

Nut and seed butters are delicious and nutritious foods that serve many functions in a healthy diet. Making your own can protect you from harmful ingredients, save you money, and encourage creativity. There are so many different nuts and seeds to experiment with, in various combinations, and with various added flavors, that you may find yourself with a new hobby: DIYing a popular pantry staple in your own kitchen.

And as long as you leave out the bacon and the frying, you may find that, like Elvis, you “can’t help falling in love” with homemade nut butters and seed butters.

Tell us in the comments:

  • Do you eat nuts and seeds? Why or why not?
  • If you use nut or seed butters, which are your favorites?
  • What kind of nut or seed butter would you like to make at home?

Read Next: